Does Love Win?: A Review of Rob Bell’s book Love Wins

6e43d-love-winsThere has been a lot of discussion around the internet about Rob Bell’s new book Love Wins. Before this, I have been a supporter of Rob Bell. I have read all of his books (except drops like stars), seen most of the nooma videos, and watched two of his longer videos. And while I have not always agreed with him, I think that he’s a great communicator and has brought some great insights to the table. That being said, while I try not involve myself in internet debates, but I felt that it was appropriate to share with the few people who read my blog about Love Wins and what Bell actually says in the book (You should check out my friend David’s blog post about this as well).

There were a lot of people crying heresy and accusing Rob Bell of universalism. Those claims were based mostly off of the title and a book trailer. After actually reading the book, I believe that claims of Bell’s flee from Orthodox Christianity have been greatly exaggerated.

So what does he say?

First, he plainly says that there is a heaven, a hell, a final judgment, a bodily resurrection and that there will be a new heaven and new earth. Is this Biblical? Yes. Second, he says that Jesus is the only one through which people receive salvation. Is this Biblical? Yes.

So far, so good.

He begins to stray from the pack in his discussion of who gets spend eternity with God and the permanency of hell. He believes that because God is love, he would never be so exclusive as to make salvation dependent on human effort to spread the gospel. God works in ways that we don’t know to save people who would never receive the gospel. It would be unloving for God to never give some people the chance to receive the grace that he so freely gives to all people if they will choose to follow.

Is this Biblical? Bell would say yes. I would say only God knows. God tells us to make disciples of all peoples and we should leave the rest up to God.

He also argues that the gates of New Jerusalem will not be shut and that there will still be opportunity for people to turn to Jesus after the final trumpet sounds

Is this Biblical? Sort of. The gates of New Jerusalem never shut, but I don’t agree with Bell’s interpretation. The verse says that the gates never shut because there is no night. My interpretation: God is in the city, he has banished the darkness (symbolic of evil) there is no more night (symbolic of evil), therefore there is no need to lock the gates, there is no need for security measures. New Jerusalem is safe because God has defeated evil once and for all.

So Heretic? Probably not. Stretching the interpretation of some scriptures? Yes. His interpretation, however, do not negate the saving power of Jesus and Jesus alone. Therefore, he’s not a universalist either. If you need a label, he’s an inclusivist. In his opinion there are people who will be saved (through Jesus) that we wouldn’t expect.

Honestly, this is nothing new. There have been many Christians through the centuries to hold this. One of whom is C. S. Lewis. Although he never wrote a book specifically about this area of theology, one example is found in the Last Battle Lewis shows a Calormean entering Aslan’s country who never followed Aslan. Aslan tells him that all the good he did for Tash, he actually did for Aslan. Another, although it’s more like a parable than theology, is the story of the Great Divorce. A group of deceased ride a bus from Hell to Heaven and are given a chance to follow God even though they have already died and gone to Hell. These are both similar to Love Wins, but it should be remembered that these are both stories and not theological explanations.

Why did Bell write this book? Because he is so convicted by the fact that God is love, that he believes should show that love to all people. I think that most of us can get behind that. Christians should be known as a people of love because God is love. God loves people and in the end God’s love rules the day. In other words, Love Wins.

6 thoughts on “Does Love Win?: A Review of Rob Bell’s book Love Wins

  1. KC Leonard 03/25/2011 / 5:13 pm

    Thanks for posting this, Peter. I have not read this book yet, mainly because of the controversy. Now after reading your review I am more inclined to read this book. Though, since we went through Velvet Elvis for SFG sophomore year, I haven't read anything by Bell, so I'm not real sure what I should read next, what you do you?

  2. KC Leonard 03/25/2011 / 5:14 pm

    Oops…that last line is “what do you think?”***

  3. Peter Stevens 03/25/2011 / 5:18 pm

    He's only written a few books. I've read velvet Elvis, sex god, and Jesus wants to save Christians. They're all good. I'd start with velvet Elvis. After that it doesn't really matter what you read. They're all fairly quick reads too.

  4. David Mosley 03/26/2011 / 9:07 am

    KC,

    I don't think it much matters. I've only read Sex God and Love Wins by Bell. For me, the purpose of reading Love Wins was to gain insight on all the controversy.

  5. Robbie and Megan 06/23/2011 / 10:45 am

    I haven't talked to any of you guys for awhile, but I really appreciate both your review of the book Peter and your review David. I've got the book sitting here on my desk and I'm going to get to it when I have a chance. But I thank you for taking the time to read it and then giving an honest interpretation.

    KC, again, it's been awhile. I've read each of Bell's books, (only some of Sex God) but where ever you start, it really doesn't matter.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s